Special Sections » Holiday Guide

The Best Music of 2009

Our critics recommend the year's best in folk, hip-hop, metal, jazz, rock, R&B, and more — both here and abroad.



Stefon Harris & Blackout, Urbanus

Leaving his prestigious post at SFJAZZ Collective may have been a salutary thing for vibraphonist Stefon Harris. His side project, Blackout, features a group of heavyweights — pianist Marc Carey, saxophonist Casey Benjamin, bassist Ben "B Dub" Williams, and drummer Terreon "Tank" Gully — who all have roots in the jazz tradition, but still give it plenty of latitude. Harris formed Blackout several years ago before taking a hiatus. Now he's returned with a surprising mix of tunes, most of them arranged in a peculiar, funky way. The highlight is a cover of Stevie Wonder's "They Won't Go (When I Go)," which sets Benjamin's vocoder against a bass clarinet — an illogical combination that dazzles. It lies among several other groove-oriented ballads, including a stylish interpretation of the Buster Williams tune "Christina." Carey's piece "The Afterthought" gives Urbanus enough bustling energy to make good on its name. Harris has a deep and far-ranging ear, and a habit of singing audibly through all his solos. He's conversant not only in straight-ahead but also R&B, funk, and avant-garde forms — and Urbanus explores all of them. (Concord)

M.F. Doom, Unexpected Guests

Some rappers think it best to construct a persona at the front end of each other their albums, then inhabit it. Others reveal themselves in bits and pieces, hiding beneath pop culture allusions or oblique language. M.F. Doom obviously belongs to the latter school, and he's one of the few artists who does it right. In his first verse on Unexpected Guests Doom reimagines himself — aptly— as part-Muhammad Ali, part-Aesop fabler (i.e., he hits hard and spins yarns that careen in every direction). Fans of Doom's previous material will find a lot to like here, from the odd-bar flows to the aphorisms, the untraceable samples, the recurring metaphors, and the winking references. And as its title indicates, Unexpected Guests is anything but predictable. The guest artists offer many surprises of their own, from Ghostface's cameo on "Angels" to Masta Killa's rap on "E.N.Y. House," (which bobbles quotes from Mad Cobra and Blahzay Blahzay). Still, Doom stands head and shoulders above the rest. (Gold Dust Media)

Vijay Iyer Trio, Historicity

While his peers try to propel the jazz tradition into contemporary hip-hop and R&B, pianist Vijay Iyer has burdened himself with an even riskier cross-pollination. His version of jazz bleeds into just about every pop genre that exists, but still takes itself seriously as jazz. Iyer's new album Historicity careens in every direction, with a riveting cover of the M.I.A. hit "Galang" (with the piano playing all her synthetic bleeps and blips), the oft-sampled Ronnie Foster fusion track "Mystic Brew," and even a zigzag-y version of Leonard Bernstein's ballad "Somewhere." His interpretation of the Stevie Wonder tune "Big Brother" is disarming, with quivery bowed bass by Stephen Crump and weird accents by drummer Marcus Gilmore. In its totality, Historicity is the type of exposition that all modern jazz musicians are trying to create. It's diffuse in terms of reach, but lean in format. Iyer is clearly a well-disciplined and rigorous musician, but his imagination has no checks. (Act Music & Vision)

Robert Glasper , Double Booked

Keyboard Robert Glasper carved out his own hipster marketing niche by mixing hip-hop with jazz in a way that actually seemed credible. Double Booked culminates an experiment that Glasper began, tentatively, in his 2005 album Canvas, and continued in 2007's In My Element (which features jazz songs based on J Dilla samples). This time, he went all the way. As the title suggests, Double Booked is half jazz (and gospel-style jazz, at that), with five originals by Glasper and one inspired version of a Monk tune, all performed by Glasper's trio (Vicente Archer plays bass, drummer Chris "Daddy" Dave keeps time). The other half is jazzy R&B, with vocoder by Casey Benjamin (whose soulful interpretation of "Butterfly" recalls the original Herbie Hancock record), Derrick Hodge on electric bass, Jahi Sundance on turntables, and two unforgettable cameos by Bilal. It's a self-consciously hip lineup, but beneath all that gloss, the music has depth and sophistication. Even a purist would get into it. (Blue Note)

Raekwon, Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... Pt. II

All bets were off when Raekwon decided to make a comeback this year with, of all things, a sequel to his classic 1995 release, Only Built 4 Cuban Linx. It's a nostalgia-based gangster album, but this time, Raekwon delivers. His rhymes paint all the sordid details of an imaginary New York neighborhood that only exists on Wu Tang albums: Men step out of their apartments and shank each other, crack is the main export, every day marks a new recon mission. Fans of classic Wu Tang will appreciate the samurai whooshes, B-movie samples, and James Cagney rap style. Raekwon and his brethren (which include Ghostface, Inspectah Deck, Masta Killa, and Method Man) have a medieval sense of retributive justice, but their observations are fascinating: One of the best tracks is "Pyrex Vision," a 54-second monologue about crack, with a beat supplied by Marley Marl. It's one of many surprises. (Ice H2O)

Wale, Attention Deficit

That ubiquitous single "Chillin" — with Lady GaGa on the hook, modulating her voice to sound exactly like M.I.A. — helped cement Wale's status as a crossover artist, but it's actually the least interesting track on an otherwise promising debut. By "promising," I mean a little to the left of what you'd expect from someone with major label backing, and production credits from Mark Ronson (the man behind Amy Winehouse's "Rehab"). Ronson obviously saw a lot of potential in Wale, a DC-based hip-hop artist who came up performing with a nine-piece go-go band. He naturally inclines toward syncopated rhythms and tends to rap with a swingy, dotted-eighth feel. Wale's cadence will draw you right in, but it's his intellect that really sustains the fourteen tracks of Attention Deficit. From flipping well-known samples by Tribe and Kool & the Gang, to adopting a woman's perspective in "Diary" — based on a loop from "La Valse D'Amélie" — Wale shows himself to be a clever and versatile emcee. Right off the bat, he references Michael Vick, Slum Dog Millionaire, and radio "snap jams" (i.e., minstrelsy). For someone with such a huge marketing machine behind him, that's unexpectedly thoughtful. (Allido/Interscope)